Gorgeous Tiffany themed wedding

@ Easton Fashion Night 2015

Custom cakes to make every birthday special

 

“Loved My Cupcakes” – theknot.com

Reviewed on 9/27/2013

The cupcakes they did for my wedding were adorable and tasty! I took in a picture and they were exactly what I was looking for. The only regret I have is I wish I had them make my cake too. A+++++++++++

Kellie K

5.0
2015-06-12T19:53:49+00:00

Kellie K

Reviewed on 9/27/2013 The cupcakes they did for my wedding were adorable and tasty! I took in a picture and they were exactly what I was looking for. The only regret I have is I wish I had them make my cake too. A+++++++++++

“Perfect” – theknot.com

Reviewed on 7/13/2014

Our wedding cake was so beautiful. She really thinks of the cake like a piece of art and everything about how it looked was absolutely perfect. And then there was the actual taste of the cake. I've never tasted better. We had strawberry for one layer and dark chocolate for another. Luckily, we live near the shop, so we can come in for the amazing cupcakes anytime.

Ariel F

5.0
2015-06-12T19:54:02+00:00

Ariel F

Reviewed on 7/13/2014 Our wedding cake was so beautiful. She really thinks of the cake like a piece of art and everything about how it looked was absolutely perfect. And then there was the actual taste of the cake. I’ve never tasted better. We had strawberry for one layer and dark chocolate for another. Luckily, View Full →

“Wonderful” – weddingwire.com

Reviewed on 8/14/2010

Melissa was absolutely WONDERFUL!

My husband and I wanted something different. He loves zombie movies and I love vampire anything. So we started looking for someone that would be willing to make a cake that had the bride and groom at the top fending off the two types of monsters.

We gave Melissa some action figures and a general idea and told her to have fun. She definitely stepped up to the plate and hit a home run with this one! She was so friendly through the entire process and was very helpful! I HIGHLY RECCOMMEND her!

Michelle

5.0
2015-06-13T12:07:52+00:00

Michelle

Reviewed on 8/14/2010 Melissa was absolutely WONDERFUL! My husband and I wanted something different. He loves zombie movies and I love vampire anything. So we started looking for someone that would be willing to make a cake that had the bride and groom at the top fending off the two types of monsters. We gave View Full →

“Delicious cake for bridal shower” – yelp.com

Reviewed on 7/14/2014

My mom got a cake from here for my bridal shower and it was adorable. It was a tea themed shower and the cake had fondant tea bags and a fondant teapot, which were also delicious. The cake was moist and had a delicious but subtle almond flavor. The frosting was creamy and tasty. By the end of the shower, the cake was pretty much obliterated and my friends and I stood around it taking bites of the fondant.. So good! In terms of service and price, I can't really comment but my mom did say the employee was very kind and worked with her to create the perfect cake. Definitely recommend!

Danielle K.

5.0
2015-06-13T12:10:33+00:00

Danielle K.

Reviewed on 7/14/2014 My mom got a cake from here for my bridal shower and it was adorable. It was a tea themed shower and the cake had fondant tea bags and a fondant teapot, which were also delicious. The cake was moist and had a delicious but subtle almond flavor. The frosting was creamy View Full →

“I came in for a pick me up before work..” – Facebook

Reviewed on 6/4/2015

I came in for a pick me up before work and I was greeted with great customer service. Not only was the staff very friendly the coffee was great as well as the muffin I purchased. I will be back
5.0
2015-11-21T13:21:00+00:00
Reviewed on 6/4/2015 I came in for a pick me up before work and I was greeted with great customer service. Not only was the staff very friendly the coffee was great as well as the muffin I purchased. I will be back

“The taste of the cake at the wedding was simply the best tasting cake I have ever tasted” – Facebook

Reviewed on 8/8/2015

Very good pricing and service when I ordered my cousins wedding cake and cup cakes from this establishment. The taste of the cake at the wedding was simply the best tasting cake I have ever tasted. A++++
5.0
2015-11-21T13:17:19+00:00
Reviewed on 8/8/2015 Very good pricing and service when I ordered my cousins wedding cake and cup cakes from this establishment. The taste of the cake at the wedding was simply the best tasting cake I have ever tasted. A++++
5.0
6

We are a licensed bakery located in Pickerington Ohio specializing in gourmet and custom decorated cakes, cupcakes and cookies, cheesecakes and cake truffles using only the highest quality ingredients. We offer delicious specialty coffees & a large assortment of daily treats so you are sure to find something irresistibly yummy to take home and enjoy everyday.

Special orders are always welcome, so if you are planning a birthday or other event that requires custom decoration or a large volume of cupcakes or cookies, we can fulfill your needs. Volume and complexity of the order will determine lead time required. Our resident artist will create a unique and delicious product for your wedding or other special celebration that is sure to impress and delight your guests.

Come in to join us in the morning for breakfast!!  With delicious Scones, Muffins, Biscotti and more to go with our house and flavored freshly brewed coffee and lattes, there is no better way to start your day!

Enjoy the cozy inviting atmosphere & prompt courteous service…
We Have The Best Coffee In Pickerington!!

We Are Now Selling Our Gourmet Flavored Coffee Beans, and Espresso!
Fresh ground to your liking.

Sweet Persuasions Custom Cakes and Bake Shop

Only superior quality ingredients and never any preservatives are used in all the scratch-made baked goods. We are a licensed bakery located in Pickerington Ohio specializing in gourmet and custom decorated cakes, cupcakes and cookies, cheesecakes and cake truffles using only the highest quality ingredients. We offer delicious specialty coffees & a large assortment of daily treats so you are sure to find something irresistibly yummy to take home and enjoy everyday. Special orders are always welcome, so if you are planning a birthday or other event that requires custom decoration or a large volume of cupcakes or cookies, we can fulfill your needs. Volume and complexity of the order will determine lead time required. Our resident artist will create a unique and delicious product for your wedding or other special celebration that is sure to impress and delight your guests. Best known for our custom decorated cakes and signature items like our Ugly and Blondie Bars, we have won several accolades including the 'Best Dessert' in the Taste of Pickerington competition.
As featured on:

Locations

Our premier bakery is located @ 1260 Hill Rd.N. , Pickerington, OH, 43147

Hours

Open Close
Monday 8:00 AM 1:00 PM
Tuesday – Saturday 8:00 AM 7:00 PM
Sunday Closed

Like us on Facebook for the latest promotions and discount codes!